Tests and science3 min read

Enneagram, MBTI, 16Personalities, and Big Five: How They Differ and Which to Choose

The four best-known personality models in one table: what each describes, how well research backs it up, what it's good for, and what it costs.

Everyone offers a personality test these days, and you'll most often run into four names: the Enneagram, MBTI, 16Personalities, and Big Five. They aren't competing over which one is right. Each looks at people from a different angle, and each is good for something different.

Comparison in one table

EnneagramMBTI16PersonalitiesBig Five
What it describeswhy you act the way you do (motivations, fears)how you perceive the world and make decisionshow you behave and come across to othersthe degree of five basic personality traits
Result9 types (we call them strategies) + wing and subtype16 types (e.g., INFJ)16 types + A/T variantscores on five traits, no boxes
Research backingsmaller, but growingmoderate, results often change on retakingits own model, little independent researchstrongest, the standard in psychology
Good forself-knowledge, relationships, personal growth, teamswork and communication style, teamsquick orientation, fun, a first stepresearch, hiring, comparable results
Pricebasics often free, detailed reports paidofficial test paidtest free, extended profiles paidfree versions widely available

Enneagram: why you do what you do

The Enneagram describes nine basic strategies for coping with life. It doesn't just ask how you behave, but above all why: what drives you and what you fear. Two people can behave the same way for completely different reasons. That's what makes the Enneagram powerful for relationships and personal growth. It shows where you get in your own way and what you do automatically under pressure.

Weakness: there are fewer scientific studies on it than on Big Five, and the result depends heavily on the quality of the test and the descriptions.

MBTI: how you perceive and decide

MBTI (Myers-Briggs) sorts people into 16 types based on four pairs of preferences, such as introversion vs. extraversion or thinking vs. feeling. It's well known in companies and helps people talk about work and communication styles.

Weakness: people often get a different result when they retake it, and the model splits continuous traits into sharp boxes.

16Personalities: the popular starting point

16Personalities uses letters similar to MBTI (INFP, ESTJ…), but it's its own model with an added A/T variant. The test is free, quick, and the results are written in a readable way, which is why it's so well known in the Czech Republic. For many people, it's their first experience of personality being something you can describe.

Weakness: it describes behaviour more than motivation, and there's little independent research.

Big Five: the scientific standard

Big Five measures five traits: openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and emotional stability. It doesn't give you types but scores on a scale, so it's more precise and has the strongest research backing. It's used in psychology and in hiring.

Weakness: a result like “you're 70% conscientious” is accurate, but it doesn't say much about what to do with that in your life.

When to reach for which

  • Want to understand yourself, your reactions, and your relationships? Enneagram.
  • Working on work and communication style in a team? MBTI or the Enneagram, ideally with a good interpretation.
  • Want a quick, fun first look? 16Personalities.
  • Need the most precise, comparable measurement? Big Five.

The models don't rule each other out. Many people know their 16Personalities type, and the Enneagram adds what was missing: why they behave the way they do. If that interests you, find out your strategy. It takes 10 minutes and a few questions about you.